Question: Is the modern State of Israel, established in 1948, the Israel promised in the Bible? How does it relate to the ancient nation of Israel in the Old Testament?

Answer: I have visited modern Israel twice. I admire much of the country’s development and have been impressed by Jewish culture, education, and history. Visiting Yad Vashem also helped me understand more deeply the suffering Jewish people have endured. In October 2022, I looked out over Jerusalem’s Old City from the Mount of Olives—a place of profound significance to Jews, Christians, and Muslims alike.

In February 2024, I attended a lecture on the Israel–Hamas war given by Palestinian pastor Alex Awad, author of Palestinian Memories. Hearing a Palestinian Christian perspective challenged me to understand Palestinian experiences as well, rather than viewing the conflict only through Israeli eyes.

Henry with Palestinian Christian author Alex Awad after a lecture in February 2024
With Alex Awad, author of Palestinian Memories, after his lecture in February 2024.

Most of my research notes for this article began during the early months of the war between Israel and Hamas in 2023. As I watched civilians suffer, I kept returning to a question: Is the modern State of Israel the Israel promised in Scripture? I believe we must begin with the biblical texts rather than deciding in advance which side to support. This article focuses on the biblical land promises; it is not a comprehensive history or legal assessment of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. Criticism of the Israeli government should not be confused with hostility toward Jewish people.

1. What Did God Promise Abraham?

God called Abram, promised to make him a great nation, and declared that all the families of the earth would be blessed through him (Genesis 12:1–3). Later, God promised Canaan to him and his descendants as an enduring possession (Genesis 17:8). This is a real promise of land. We should not dismiss it simply because we disagree with Christian Zionism. But does an enduring possession necessarily mean that the land must remain under the same form of Israelite political control in every age?

The Old Testament itself warns us not to separate the promise from the covenant relationship. Leviticus 26 and Deuteronomy 28–30 repeatedly warn Israel that covenant unfaithfulness will lead to the loss of the land and exile among the nations. Jeremiah 7:5–7 links remaining in the land to acting justly, refusing to oppress the foreigner, and not shedding innocent blood. These warnings eventually became reality. Yet God also promised restoration through the prophets, and Leviticus 26:44–45 makes clear that exile did not mean he had utterly rejected his covenant with Israel. God’s continuing faithfulness to Israel and the question of whether the original territorial arrangements must remain unchanged are not the same issue.

There is another instructive example. In 1 Samuel 2:30, God recalls his earlier promise that Eli’s family would minister before him continually, but because of their unfaithfulness, he announces that the former arrangement will not continue. This does not mean every biblical promise described as everlasting can simply be cancelled. Nor does Eli’s case by itself prove that the promise of Canaan to Abraham has ended. It does, however, remind us that God’s faithfulness does not require every earlier arrangement to remain intact regardless of the recipients’ unfaithfulness.

More importantly, how does the New Testament understand these promises? Jesus declares in Matthew 5:5 (ESV), “Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth.” This echoes Psalm 37 and its hope that the righteous will inherit the land. Jesus does not define the heirs here by ethnicity or political sovereignty. Paul likewise teaches that Abraham is the father not only of Jews but also of those who share his faith (Romans 4:11–17). Those who belong to Christ, whether Jew or Gentile, are Abraham’s offspring and heirs according to the promise (Galatians 3:26–29). Romans 4:13 speaks of Abraham and his offspring inheriting the world, not merely Canaan.

These passages do not explicitly cancel the promise concerning Canaan. They do, however, show that the New Testament understands both the heirs and the scope of the inheritance more broadly in Christ. God’s purpose in calling Abraham was never simply to give one people a territory; from the beginning, it included blessing all nations. This is also the theme of my article “Why Did God Choose Israel? From Babel and the Nations to Christ”.

2. Was the Land Promise Fulfilled, and Does It Still Have a Future?

Joshua 21:43–45 explicitly says that God gave Israel the land he had promised their ancestors and that none of his good promises failed. We therefore cannot say that the land promise remained entirely unfulfilled until the establishment of Israel in 1948.

Yet this does not mean that everything God promised Israel was already complete. Israel later lost its land and went into exile, while the prophets announced a future return. Ezra records the return of Jewish exiles during the Persian period. But the restoration envisioned in Ezekiel 36–37 involves more than returning to a geographical location. God promises to cleanse his people, give them a new heart and spirit, shepherd them through his servant David, establish an everlasting covenant of peace, and dwell among them (Ezekiel 36:24–27; 37:24–28).

From a New Testament perspective, significant aspects of these promises have begun to be fulfilled in Christ. Jesus is David’s descendant, and his kingdom will have no end (Luke 1:32–33). God dwells among his people through the Spirit, and Jews and Gentiles are brought together in Christ as members of God’s household (Ephesians 2:14–22). Jesus is the king Israel awaited, but his kingdom is not restricted to the Jewish nation. Beginning in Israel, the good news goes out to all nations. This does not reduce the Old Testament promises to something merely abstract or “spiritual.” Rather, God’s purposes find a wider fulfillment in Christ.

Whether there will also be a future political kingdom specifically for the Jewish people remains open to discussion. Ezekiel 37:25 does speak of the ancestral land, and we cannot simply ignore it. In Acts 1:6–8, the disciples ask Jesus when he will restore the kingdom to Israel. Jesus does not directly rule out the possibility, but he redirects their attention to the coming of the Holy Spirit and their mission to bear witness from Jerusalem to the ends of the earth. At the very least, the New Testament’s central concern is not to instruct disciples to re-establish a Jewish political state, but to bear witness to Jesus as king so that all nations may know him.

Ezekiel 40–48 also portrays a future temple and sacrifices. Yet I do not find a New Testament command to rebuild the temple or restore the Old Testament sacrificial system. Hebrews 7–10 teaches that Christ offered himself once for all and secured eternal redemption; where sins have been forgiven, no further offering for sin is required (Hebrews 10:10–18). Jesus speaks of his own body as the temple (John 2:19–21). Paul describes the church as a dwelling place for God by the Spirit, with Christ as the cornerstone (Ephesians 2:19–22; see also 1 Corinthians 3:16–17). In the new Jerusalem, there is no separate temple because God and the Lamb are its temple (Revelation 21:22). I therefore lean toward understanding Ezekiel’s temple vision as ultimately pointing to God’s dwelling with his people through Christ, rather than requiring Christians to expect the restoration of the old sacrificial system. This is my reading of the biblical canon as a whole, not an explicit statement made by Ezekiel himself.

Even if God has a particular future purpose for the Jewish people, it does not follow that the modern State of Israel, established in 1948, must be the fulfillment of these restoration prophecies. What the New Testament clearly announces is Christ’s reign, the gift of the Spirit, blessing for the nations, and God’s ultimate dwelling with humanity. The precise future political arrangements of the Jewish people are not its central emphasis.

3. Does the New Testament Teach That God Has Rejected the Jewish People?

I do not believe God has rejected the Jewish people. Paul explicitly rejects that conclusion in Romans 11:1. He warns Gentile believers not to boast over the natural branches and says that Israel remains beloved for the sake of the patriarchs, because God’s gifts and calling are irrevocable (Romans 11:17–29). The simplistic claim that “the church has replaced the Jews, so God no longer cares about them” does not do justice to this passage and can encourage antisemitism.

At the same time, the New Testament interprets Abraham’s promises in relation to Christ. Paul says that those who belong to Christ are Abraham’s offspring and heirs of the promise (Galatians 3:26–29; see Romans 4). Jesus tells the Samaritan woman that salvation comes from the Jews, but also that worship of the Father will no longer be confined to Mount Gerizim or Jerusalem (John 4:19–23). The Jewish people’s place in salvation history is not erased, but worship is no longer restricted to one geographical location.

There are serious differences of interpretation over how the promise concerning “all Israel” in Romans 11:26 will be fulfilled. I do not think this article can settle that question. Even if we anticipate a future large-scale turning of Jewish people to Christ, a further argument is still required to show that the secular state established in 1948 automatically inherits the political standing of ancient covenant Israel. Ethnic and historical continuity does not mean that every covenant institution and entitlement continues unchanged.

4. Was the Establishment of Israel in 1948 the Fulfillment of Prophecy?

After centuries of dispersion and persecution, the establishment of a modern Jewish state was unquestionably a major historical event. We may be thankful that Jewish people were able to rebuild a national home and may even see God’s providential care in this history. But that is not the same as demonstrating that a particular biblical prophecy was fulfilled in 1948.

Christian Zionism broadly describes Christian approaches that see a continuing special relationship between the Jewish people’s return to the land of Israel and God’s biblical promises. Some Christian Zionists interpret the establishment of the state in 1948 as a fulfillment of end-times prophecy and therefore believe Christians should support Israel. Not every Christian who supports Israel is a Christian Zionist, however, and Christian Zionists do not necessarily endorse every policy of the Israeli government.

Christian Zionists may appeal to Genesis 17:8, Ezekiel 36–37, and Romans 11, arguing that the Jewish return to the land and the establishment of the modern state have eschatological significance. These passages deserve serious attention, not dismissal merely because we disagree with Christian Zionism. Gerald R. McDermott’s Israel Matters presents a position worth engaging carefully. Gary M. Burge’s Whose Land? Whose Promise?, by contrast, emphasizes reading the land promises in the context of the whole Bible, Christ, and the demands of justice. Roger Olson’s discussion of Christian Zionism and Alex Awad’s article also provide useful points of comparison.

Even if God intends Abraham’s descendants to dwell again in their ancestral land, we cannot simply assume that the founding of the state in 1948 was the fulfillment of prophecy, much less that today’s borders, government policies, or military actions have divine approval. Ezekiel 36:22–27 even suggests that God can begin gathering his people before their inner renewal is complete. Thus, the secular character of the modern state is not, by itself, proof that it cannot be part of God’s historical purposes. But “God may be at work in these events” is not the same as “Scripture has established that this state possesses divinely granted political rights.” God’s faithfulness to the Jewish people does not mean that he approves everything the Israeli government does.

5. Does Being Chosen Give Israel a Right to Other People’s Land and Lives?

I do not rule out the possibility that the gathering of modern Jewish communities in their ancestral homeland has some relationship to the promised return from exile. Even so, whether that return has theological significance and whether each subsequent acquisition or expansion of territory by the Israeli government is consistent with God’s will are two separate questions. Even if the first is true, the second does not automatically follow.

Consider Gaza. Was it part of the land promised to Israel? Joshua 15:47 includes ancient Gaza in the territory allotted to Judah, while Joshua 13:2–3 identifies it as one of the Philistine cities among the territories not yet taken. These passages distinguish between territorial allotment and actual control. Moreover, ancient Gaza and its surroundings cannot simply be equated with the entire modern Gaza Strip. Even if ancient Gaza was included within a biblical allotment or promise, this does not establish that God has authorized the modern State of Israel to occupy or annex Gaza.

The Old Testament does not present election as a license to oppress others. Deuteronomy 2:4–5, 9, 19 forbids Israel from taking the lands of Edom, Moab, and Ammon, because God had also given land to those peoples. Leviticus 19:33–34 commands Israel to love the foreigner residing among them; Exodus 22:21–24 prohibits oppression of foreigners, widows, and orphans. Strikingly, Ezekiel 47:21–23, within its vision of a future division of the land, requires an inheritance to be allotted to resident foreigners who have raised families among the Israelites. These passages do not draw today’s national borders for us, but they make clear that God also cares about the land, livelihood, and rights of non-Israelites.

Two further biblical narratives are instructive. When David sought to build an altar on the threshing floor of Araunah the Jebusite, he insisted on paying for it (2 Samuel 24:18–25). Ahab and Jezebel, on the other hand, seized Naboth’s vineyard through injustice and were condemned through Elijah (1 Kings 21). Neither episode settles every modern land dispute. But both remind us that even a king of Israel could not simply use his power to take another person’s property.

Nor can the Old Testament accounts of Israel entering Canaan and God’s judgment on the Canaanites be transferred uncritically into a mandate for a modern state to expel residents. I have discussed this question separately in my article on Deuteronomy 20:16–17 and the destruction of the Canaanites (in Chinese).

6. How Should Christians View Israel and Palestine Today?

I respect the Jewish people’s historical connection to this land and grieve the persecution they have endured, especially the Holocaust. The history of Christian antisemitism demands serious reflection. Jewish people today must not be held collectively responsible for every policy of the Israeli government.

But neither can I ignore Palestinian suffering. Hamas’s attacks on civilians and hostage-taking must be condemned. When the Israeli government, military, or settlers violate civilians’ lives, dignity, or legitimate rights, they must also be held morally accountable. The title “God’s chosen people” does not exempt anyone from moral scrutiny. Palestinian Christians deserve the church’s concern; and Palestinians who are not Christians possess the same God-given human dignity.

Nor should the scale of the suffering be obscured by saying only that “both sides have suffered.” According to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), in its report dated 2 September 2026, more than 1,200 people were killed in Israel during the attacks of 7 October 2023 and their immediate aftermath. The same report, citing Gaza’s Ministry of Health, recorded 73,470 Palestinians killed and 174,540 injured in Gaza since October 2023. These figures cover different reporting periods and categories and should not be treated as a precise comparative death ratio. Nevertheless, the far greater scale of casualties in Gaza is clear.[1] Although a ceasefire agreement was reached in October 2025, violence did not cease altogether. OCHA continued to document airstrikes, gunfire, shelling, and additional casualties in November 2026.[2] Casualty figures alone do not determine whether every military operation was lawful. Yet the loss of so many lives cannot be brushed aside.

I do not believe God has rejected the Jewish people. Neither do I believe that the modern State of Israel, established in 1948, has been shown to be the direct political fulfillment of the Old Testament land promises merely because of its name, ethnic connections, or successful founding. The New Testament does not simply abolish the Old; in Christ it fulfills, deepens, and unfolds God’s earlier promises. There is still much to explore concerning God’s future purposes for the Jewish people. But I do not see sufficient biblical grounds to require Christians to regard the establishment of Israel in 1948 as the necessary fulfillment of prophecy. That does not deny the modern state’s existence; it means we should not identify its political claims with God’s will.

God’s call to Abraham was always directed toward blessing all the families of the earth (Genesis 12:3). Christians discussing Israel should therefore ask not only who possesses the land, but also: Are we being faithful to the God who loves justice and mercy and desires blessing for all nations?

Notes on Casualty Figures and Sources

  1. United Nations OCHA, Reported Impact Snapshot: Gaza Strip (2 September 2026). Palestinian casualty figures are attributed to Gaza’s Ministry of Health; Israeli fatalities are attributed to Israeli official sources as reported in the media. OCHA attributes figures not independently verified by the UN to their respective sources. ↩
  2. United Nations OCHA, Humanitarian Situation Report (18 November 2026), covering developments in Gaza during 10–16 November 2026. ↩

References and Further Reading

The following works represent different perspectives for further study. Listing them does not imply that I endorse every argument made by their authors.

Biblical Interpretation, Land, and Christian Zionism

History and the Experiences of Different Peoples

  • Simon Sebag Montefiore, Jerusalem: The Biography.
  • Ari Shavit, My Promised Land: The Triumph and Tragedy of Israel.
  • Edward W. Said, After the Last Sky: Palestinian Lives.
  • Alex Awad, Palestinian Memories: The Story of a Palestinian Mother and Her People (I have read the book and attended the author’s lecture in February 2024).
  • Ilan Pappé, Ten Myths About Israel (his historical interpretations are contested and should be compared with other scholarship).

Human Rights and Contemporary Conditions

Scripture references are to the English Standard Version (ESV). Biblical passages are generally summarized or paraphrased; the brief direct quotation of Matthew 5:5 is from the ESV.