Familiar Christian Sayings: A Biblical Examination — Part 3

Read the Chinese original

Question: We often hear that “all sins are equal in God’s eyes.” Is this true?

Answer: I often hear familiar sayings circulating among Christians: “God hates sin but loves the sinner,” “God’s love is unconditional,” “All sins are equal in God’s eyes,” “God helps those who help themselves,” “Once saved, always saved,” and “We will go to heaven.” These sayings do not themselves appear in Scripture, but they seem, to some extent, to match the surface meaning of certain passages, making their accuracy harder to assess.

What exactly do they mean? Do they agree with the Bible’s teaching as a whole? If we accept these sayings without examining them, treating them as self-evident truths, we can stop thinking. Even when reading the Bible, we may automatically filter out teachings that conflict with them. We may eventually end up teaching human commands as doctrine, rendering our worship vain (Mark 7:7).

In this series, I want to examine the problems with these familiar sayings and invite readers to reconsider whether they are true. This time, we will consider “All sins are equal in God’s eyes.”

1. The most common biblical justification

Christians frequently cite James 2:10:1

James 2:10 (ESV)

10 For whoever keeps the whole law but fails in one point has become guilty of all of it.

The inference is that, if breaking one commandment amounts to breaking them all, there is no difference between sins. Lying and murder are treated as equivalent.

This passage is often quoted alongside Romans 3:23, reinforcing the impression:2

Romans 3:23 (ESV)

23 for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God,

Since everyone has sinned, and even one transgression makes a person guilty of the whole law, the argument goes, there can be no difference between sins. We often hear this in sermons urging people not to judge others or become self-righteous. The intention is good: to remind us that everyone is a sinner and no one has grounds to look down on anyone else.

2. What James 2:10 is actually saying

When we read the passage in context, James is not arguing that every sin is equally destructive. His point is that the law is a unified whole.

The argument in James 2:8–11 is that, if you select one commandment to obey—such as not committing murder—but violate another—such as showing partiality—you remain a transgressor of the law. The law cannot be broken into separate items on a scoring sheet. Breaking it at one point makes you a lawbreaker.

In other words, James 2:10 addresses whether a violation has occurred: are you a transgressor of the law? That is a yes-or-no question. It does not address the degree of harm: do lying and murder cause the same damage? That is a question of degree. The saying confuses these two different matters.

A clarification: dividing sins into two categories does not always mean ranking their seriousness

Before examining the evidence, we should clarify something. Certain passages divide sins into two categories, but not necessarily according to their seriousness. For example:

1 John 5:16–17 (ESV)

16 If anyone sees his brother committing a sin not leading to death, he shall ask, and God will give him life—to those who commit sins that do not lead to death. There is sin that leads to death; I do not say that one should pray for that.

17 All wrongdoing is sin, but there is sin that does not lead to death.

In my article “1 John 5:16–17: What Is the ‘Sin Leading to Death’? A Fourth View,” I argue that the distinction here concerns a person’s present attitude toward sin: whether they persist without repentance and reject intercession, or remain open to repentance. It does not concern the inherent nature or destructive effect of a particular offence.

In other words, this passage distinguishes people’s spiritual condition, rather than degrees of sin. It is therefore addressing a different question, and I will not use it below as evidence that sins differ in seriousness.

This also reminds us that, when assessing whether a passage supports degrees of sin, we cannot simply observe that it classifies sins. We must ask what basis it uses for that classification.

3. Scripture explicitly distinguishes degrees of sin

If all sins really were equal in God’s eyes, Scripture should have no need to distinguish between them. Yet the evidence points in the opposite direction.

3.1 The Old Testament sacrificial system makes distinctions

Numbers 15:22–31 distinguishes unintentional sins from defiant acts, described with the imagery of acting with a high hand against God. Unintentional sins can be atoned for through sacrifice, whereas the defiant offender is to be cut off. The system itself presupposes differences in seriousness.

3.2 Jesus explicitly distinguishes degrees of judgment

Matthew 11:22 (ESV)

22 But I tell you, it will be more bearable on the day of judgment for Tyre and Sidon than for you.

Luke 12:47–48 (ESV)

47 And that servant who knew his master’s will but did not get ready or act according to his will, will receive a severe beating.

48 But the one who did not know, and did what deserved a beating, will receive a light beating. Everyone to whom much was given, of him much will be required, and from him to whom they entrusted much, they will demand the more.

“More bearable,” “a severe beating,” and “a light beating” express comparisons. They directly contradict the claim that all sins and all judgments are the same.

3.3 Jesus uses an image contrasting lesser and greater offences

Matthew 23:24 (ESV)

24 You blind guides, straining out a gnat and swallowing a camel!

Jesus rebukes the Pharisees for carefully straining even a tiny gnat out of their drink while swallowing an entire camel. The image exposes their fixation on minor details while neglecting the weightier matters of the law: justice, mercy, and faithfulness (Matthew 23:23).

The image assumes that a gnat and a camel are not on the same scale. Jesus deliberately contrasts small and large; he does not treat them as equal.

3.4 Jesus explicitly speaks of “the greater sin”

John 19:11 (ESV)

11 Jesus answered him, “You would have no authority over me at all unless it had been given you from above. Therefore he who delivered me over to you has the greater sin.”

Jesus tells Pilate directly that different people bear different degrees of guilt. There is such a thing as a greater sin.

4. What goes wrong when we insist that all sins are equal?

Apart from conflicting with these passages, a literal application of the saying can produce two opposite but equally harmful pastoral abuses.

The first is resignation: if it is all the same anyway, why not go all the way? Someone who has committed a lesser offence and is told that they are already no different from a murderer or adulterer may think, “I am already just as bad.” They may give up restraining themselves. We will return to this in the next section.

The second works in the opposite direction. Someone who has committed a serious offence may use other people’s lesser wrongs to excuse themselves: “We are all guilty of the same thing.” This blurs their responsibility and helps them avoid accountability.

Paul’s response to a situation in Corinth illustrates how a church should respond:

1 Corinthians 5:1–2 (ESV)

1 It is actually reported that there is sexual immorality among you, and of a kind that is not tolerated even among pagans, for a man has his father’s wife.

2 And you are arrogant! Ought you not rather to mourn? Let him who has done this be removed from among you.

A believer was living with his stepmother, yet the church failed to address it and was even arrogant. Paul sternly required the church to remove the man. If all sins really were equal, Paul would have no reason to react especially strongly to this case. His language concerning other problems in Corinth, such as divisions and pride, is comparatively milder. He clearly does not accept the reasoning that, because all sins are equal, this particular situation needs no special response.

These abuses appear to move in opposite directions: one abandons restraint after a lesser offence, while the other excuses a serious offence. But both make the same mistake. They turn the truth that everyone needs grace into an excuse for refusing to address differences in seriousness.

In my article “Is Merely Imagining a Sin Already Sinful?”, I also point out that evil thoughts, such as envy and hatred, count as sin just as outward acts do. But their destructive effects are not identical. This reinforces the point: counting as sin does not mean causing equal harm.

5. Similar in nature, different in degree: two examples

In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus uses striking formulations: anger makes a person liable to judgment, and lust amounts to adultery in the heart. These forceful statements remind us that dealing with sin begins with our thoughts. Hatred can develop into murderous intent—Cain is a biblical example, and contemporary news supplies many others. Lust can develop into infidelity and adultery.

Jesus places thoughts and actions on the same moral trajectory so that, before people act, they face what has already gone wrong within them.

But similarity in nature does not mean equality in degree or destructive effect. Consider early-stage and terminal cancer. Both are cancer, both require serious attention, and both require treatment. Yet the stages and treatment plans differ. No one would say, “It is all cancer anyway,” and therefore disregard its stage. Similarly:

  • Anger and actually killing someone both count as sin, but their consequences and destructive effects are vastly different. Matthew 5:22 itself presents three levels even within sins of the heart: anger brings liability to judgment, an insult brings liability to the council, and calling someone a fool brings liability to the fire of hell. Even Jesus does not flatten all inward sins into a single category of seriousness.
  • Viewing pornography and actually committing adultery or buying sex both belong within the sphere of sexual sin. Both cause real and serious damage to marriage and should not be trivialized. Yet they are different kinds of acts. Adultery and buying sex involve reciprocal physical and emotional contact with another real person; this contact directly betrays the marriage covenant. Viewing pornography is one-way consumption without relational interaction with another person. Its harm operates indirectly through deception, compulsive patterns of use, and the diversion of affection and desire. The distinction here is not a claim about which necessarily causes less harm, but about the structure of the act: direct betrayal with another person in one case, and erosion through one-way consumption in the other. Both require attention and neither should be justified. Nevertheless, because their structures differ, I do not regard them as equivalent.

Mistaking similarity in nature for equality in degree does not help repentance. It may have the opposite effect. Someone who has experienced anger or lust, and is told, “You are already the same as a murderer or adulterer,” may despair and abandon restraint.

That runs against Jesus’ purpose. He calls people to stop when sinful thoughts are beginning to take root, rather than lose heart and give up on themselves.

6. The kernel of truth in the saying

What remains valid is this: any sin, however great or small, is sufficient to rupture our relationship with God, and all of us need grace. No one can become self-righteous before God by saying, “I have committed fewer sins.”

That is what the teaching of James as a whole, alongside Romans 3:23, points toward: our universal need for grace, rather than equal destructive effects among sins.

Conclusion

“All sins are equal in God’s eyes” confuses two claims: “Any sin leaves us needing grace,” which is true, and “Every sin is equally destructive,” which is false.

Scripture clearly teaches that sins differ in seriousness and that God’s judgment takes account of each person’s circumstances. At the same time, having committed “lesser” sins does not exempt anyone from needing Christ’s redemption.

Should we, then, exaggerate the seriousness of sin in pastoral care to make people more afraid and more likely to repent? Or might doing so convince them that they are beyond hope and make them afraid to confess?

Could apparently opposite approaches make the same underlying mistake—using degrees of seriousness to manipulate people’s responses, rather than helping them see honestly what they have done and understand that grace is sufficient to cover it?

Reference

Roger E. Olson, Questions to All Your Answers: The Journey from Folk Religion to Examined Faith (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2007), chapter 8: “All Sins Are Equal: So Is Reusing a Stamp as Bad as Murder?”

Familiar Christian Sayings: A Biblical Examination

Related articles

Several authors identify a misreading of James 2:10 as a source of this popular claim. These include Brittany Ann, “Are All Sins Equal in the Eyes of God?” (equippinggodlywomen.com); Derek Rishmawy, “Are All Sins Really ‘Equal in the Eyes of God’?” (Reformedish, 2014); and related articles from Credo House Ministries. They offer similar observations and examine the argument in detail. 2: In the same article, Rishmawy also observes that Romans 3:23 is often cited alongside James 2:10, reinforcing the impression that all sins are equal. ↩