If God is all-powerful and knew that human history would contain so much sin, war, disease, and suffering, why did he not create the new heaven and new earth from the very beginning?

Revelation 21:4 tells us that there will be no more death, mourning, crying, or pain. Since God will ultimately create such a world, why not begin there directly and spare humanity so much suffering throughout history?

A recent theological conversation prompted me to think about this question again.

Perhaps we need to begin by asking: What did God create human beings for?

God Wants People to Love Him Freely

I believe God created human beings not merely so that someone would exist, nor even merely so that someone would exist forever, but so that people would know him, love him, and enter into a genuine relationship with him.

1 John 4:19 (ESV 2025)

19 We love because he first loved us.

God loves us first, extends grace to us, and draws us to respond to him. Romans 2:4 likewise speaks of God’s kindness as intended to lead people to repentance.

I believe God wants people to love him, but love should be voluntary. If someone has no opportunity to choose at all, can we still say that the person sincerely loves the other?

God is not asking us to earn his love through our own efforts. He loves us first, gives us the opportunity to know him, and allows us to respond voluntarily. This is an important reason, as I understand it, why God gives human beings freedom.

Why Not Simply Create People Who Will Love God Forever?

But the question remains. Since God ultimately wants people to live with him forever, why not create, from the outset, people who freely love him and will never sin?

I believe people will still have freedom in the new heaven and new earth, yet will no longer sin. I have discussed this in “Will We Still Be Free in the New Heaven and New Earth If We No Longer Sin?”

Freedom does not mean that sin must occur. A person can freely choose what is good and freely love God without needing to sin to prove that they are free.

Could God, then, simply create people who have never gone through a process of choosing, yet already freely and sincerely love him? Frankly, I cannot work out whether this is possible.

If they were already programmed to love God inevitably from the moment they were created, would that still count as free love? But if they could truly choose freely, how could it be guaranteed that they would never reject him?

I do not know the answer.

What I can understand, however, is that a relationship built through getting to know one another, falling in love, and committing voluntarily is different from a relationship arranged from the outset.

Scripture shows God continually extending grace and calling people to respond. He wants them to know him and be willing to follow him. Perhaps this is an important part of the meaning of our present journey through life.

Eternal Life Is More Than Existing Forever

John 17:3 connects eternal life with knowing the only true God and Jesus Christ whom he sent. First John 5:11–12 likewise points out that eternal life is God’s gift and that this life is in his Son.

Human beings are not themselves the source of eternal life. Eternal life is a gift from God.

First Corinthians 15 says that our present bodies are perishable, whereas our future resurrection bodies will be imperishable. Paul’s “spiritual body” does not mean that we will become souls without bodies, but a resurrected body given life by the Holy Spirit.

Eternal life, then, is more than our present life prolonged indefinitely. More importantly, it means entering into an eternal relationship with the living God. In Revelation 21:3, one of the most important features of the new heaven and new earth is that God will dwell with humanity.

Marriage in This Age Foreshadows the Future Relationship

I think this is also an important part of why God established marriage in this age.

Ephesians 5:31–32 quotes the passage about husband and wife becoming one flesh, but goes on to say that this mystery refers to the relationship between Christ and the church.

Marriage enables two previously independent people to come to know one another, fall in love, commit voluntarily, and build a shared life. This also helps us understand the relationship between humanity and God more concretely.

Jesus says that at the resurrection people neither marry nor are given in marriage (Matthew 22:30). In Revelation, the relationship between Christ and his people is described through the marriage supper of the Lamb, the bride’s readiness, and God dwelling with humanity (Revelation 19:7–9; 21:2–3).

Perhaps marriage in this age gives us a foretaste of this eternal relationship. When the union of God and his people is finally fulfilled, the institution of marriage in this age will no longer need to continue.

This helps me understand more clearly that God wants more than people existing forever. He wants people truly to know him, voluntarily to love him, and ultimately to dwell with him forever.

This World Is Good in Itself

Does this mean, however, that our present life serves only to determine whether we will receive eternal life in the future? I do not think so.

In “Was God’s Original Creation Perfect? Why Natural Disasters, Disease, and Death?”, I discussed how Genesis 1:31 describes everything God made as “very good,” which does not necessarily mean that the world was already in its final, completed state from the beginning.

God created human beings to govern the earth, cultivate it, and work. This in itself means that people need to make an effort and will face challenges.

We do not need to regard only a world entirely without difficulty as a good world. Mountains, rivers, oceans, wind, rain, and the forces of nature all have their distinctive beauty. In facing challenges, people can learn, explore, exercise creativity, and demonstrate courage, perseverance, cooperation, and love.

Difficulty can sometimes itself be part of what is good in life.

Of course, this does not mean that all suffering is good. The challenge of climbing a mountain can be enjoyable, but a landslide that takes lives is a tragedy. Disease, natural disasters, and especially the suffering of innocent people remain questions we cannot fully answer.

Yet I believe this world is itself God’s good creation, rather than a failed work or merely an examination hall where people determine whether they can enter eternal life.

The Cost of Freedom

God gives people freedom so that they can truly love, but people may also abuse that freedom and choose to hurt others.

In “Was It Worth Giving Humanity Freedom If It Led to So Much Evil?”, I discussed why God does not restrict human freedom to reduce evil and suffering in the world.

My conclusion then was that God gives people freedom not for freedom’s own sake, but to enable love. I still hold that view.

God wants people to do good and love one another, rather than to sin. The evil caused by human abuse of freedom is not the purpose for which God created freedom.

Nor do we need to find a particular reason arranged by God for every evil event. God can bring good out of evil, as when Joseph’s brothers intended to harm him but God brought about a good outcome (Genesis 50:20). This does not mean that what the brothers originally did was right.

God will ultimately judge evil precisely because those evils are truly evil.

As for the suffering caused by earthquakes, tsunamis, disease, and other forces of nature, human freedom alone cannot explain it. The view of creation mentioned above can help us understand why a world with natural regularities and challenges can still be good, but it cannot explain what happens to every individual who suffers.

I do not believe suffering is the purpose of God’s creation, nor do I believe that genuine love must pass through suffering in order to exist.

God wants people to love him freely, and suffering is a possible cost in this world of real freedom that has not yet reached completion.

God Has Also Experienced Suffering

If God knew that this world would bring so much pain, did he simply leave humanity to bear it alone? The life of Jesus Christ leads me to see things differently.

Philippians 2:5–8 describes Christ humbling himself, taking the form of a servant, and finally becoming obedient to death.

Jesus experienced hunger, weariness, sorrow, betrayal, and an unjust trial, and was finally crucified. God did not remain outside suffering. In Christ, he personally entered human history and experienced human pain.

Romans 5:8 says that Christ died for us while we were still sinners, demonstrating God’s love for us.

This makes me think that God does not demand that we pay every cost while bearing nothing himself. He loves us first and pays a cost for us.

Nor is suffering in this age the end of the story. God will judge evil and promises resurrection and the new heaven and new earth.

Revelation 21:4 tells us that God will wipe away every tear from his people’s eyes, and there will be no more death, mourning, crying, or pain.

Revelation 21:4 (ESV 2025)

4 He will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain anymore, for the former things have passed away."

What about those who have been victimized but ultimately do not receive eternal life? How will God deal with the injustice they have suffered? I do not know.

But I believe God is just and loving. He knows each person’s experience and will not overlook the harm they have suffered. Even though I do not know what he will do, I still have reason to trust that he will deal with it justly.

Why Didn’t God Create the New Heaven and New Earth from the Beginning?

Let us return to the original question.

I do not know whether God could directly create people who have never gone through a process of choosing, yet already freely and sincerely love him.

But I believe that God wants more than a group of people who exist forever. He wants people who truly know him, voluntarily love him, and are willing to enter into an eternal relationship with him.

God loves us first and draws us by grace, giving us the opportunity to know him and respond to him.

Our present life is also more than a worthless transitional stage. This world has its goodness. People can live, learn, explore, build relationships, and practice genuine goodness within it.

Of course, people may also abuse freedom and cause harm; nature’s limitations and dangers likewise bring suffering.

God has not made suffering his purpose, nor has he allowed death and evil to be the final outcome.

In Christ, he personally entered human suffering, and through resurrection and new creation he makes it possible for those willing to love him to dwell with him forever.

I may not be able to answer why God did not choose another way to create, but I believe that what he desires to establish is a genuine, voluntary, and eternal relationship of love.

Related Reading

Was God’s Original Creation Perfect?

Will We Still Be Free in the New Heaven and New Earth If We No Longer Sin?

Was It Worth Giving Humanity Freedom If It Led to So Much Evil?

Scripture quotations marked ESV are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. ESV Text Edition: 2025. The ESV text may not be quoted in any publication made available to the public by a Creative Commons license. The ESV may not be translated in whole or in part into any other language. Used by permission. All rights reserved.